🦇 Who Could Play Batgirl?
With the DC Universe undergoing a major shake-up under James Gunn and Peter Safran, fans are already speculating on who will don the cowl as Batgirl. If DC wants to invest in a long-term actor who can carry the role for the next decade, the choice becomes even trickier — balancing age, talent, fan appeal, and the ability to grow with the character.
Here’s a look at some of the most talked-about names, their credentials, and how they might bring Barbara Gordon to life.
🎭 Emma Stone
Emma Stone’s name always comes up when comic fans discuss strong female leads. Known for her roles in La La Land, Cruella, and of course Gwen Stacy in The Amazing Spider-Man series, Stone has proven she can handle both heart and grit. However, at 35, she might be older than DC’s desired long-term Batgirl plan — unless they decide to explore a more seasoned Barbara Gordon in a post-Batman Gotham.
🔥 Sophie Turner
Best known as Sansa Stark in Game of Thrones and Jean Grey in X-Men: Dark Phoenix, Sophie Turner has both fantasy and superhero experience. At 29, she could play Batgirl for a decade and bring a mix of elegance and toughness to the role. Her height and commanding screen presence would fit a Barbara Gordon who’s equally intelligent and physically capable.
🕵️ Madison Lintz
For comic book fans, Madison Lintz is already a familiar face from The Walking Dead and Bosch. At 25, she has the right age for a long-term casting and could portray Barbara’s evolution from idealistic vigilante to experienced crimefighter. Lintz isn’t a household name yet, but that could work in her favour for a franchise looking for fresh star power.
🌟 Zoey Deutch
Zoey Deutch (Set It Up, Zombieland: Double Tap) has been a rising star thanks to her sharp comedic timing and strong on-screen charisma. At 29, she’s young enough to commit to a long run but experienced enough to carry emotional weight. Her wit could shine through in Batgirl’s more sarcastic moments while still nailing the darker, grittier side of Gotham.
🎯 Sadie Sink
Fresh off her breakout in Stranger Things, Sadie Sink is only 22 — perfect for a decade-long arc. She brings youthful energy but also emotional intensity, as seen in The Whale. Casting her could give DC a fresh, dynamic Batgirl who appeals to a younger audience while holding her own in darker narratives.
🦹 Jenna Ortega
Jenna Ortega has already built a huge fan base from Wednesday, Scream, and X. At 22, she’s young enough for a long-term commitment and has already proven she can carry a franchise. Her mix of gothic charm and fierce determination would make her a compelling Batgirl — though her existing commitments might be a challenge for scheduling.
📚 Emma Watson
Globally known for playing Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter series, Emma Watson has both fan loyalty and acting depth. At 35, she would fit better in a more mature Batgirl storyline — perhaps as a veteran hero mentoring younger vigilantes. Her intelligence and screen gravitas would work perfectly for Barbara Gordon’s Oracle persona if DC goes that route.
🎬 Olivia Cooke
With standout performances in Ready Player One and House of the Dragon, Olivia Cooke can balance vulnerability with resilience. At 30, she could bridge the gap between youthful Batgirl and experienced leader, offering range for future DC films.
🎭 Maude Apatow
Maude Apatow (Euphoria, The King of Staten Island) brings a grounded realism to her roles. At 26, she has the right mix of youth and experience, though her more dramatic acting style might lead to a darker, more emotionally complex Batgirl.
🚫 Isabela Merced
Isabela Merced (Dora and the Lost City of Gold, Rosaline) has the charisma and action chops for Batgirl — but she’s already been cast in James Gunn’s Superman as Hawkgirl, making her a no-go for this role.
🧠 Final Thoughts
Casting Batgirl is about more than just looks — it’s about finding someone who can evolve with Barbara Gordon’s journey for 10+ years, from rookie vigilante to Gotham legend. Whether DC chooses a fresh face like Sadie Sink or Madison Lintz, or goes for an established star like Zoey Deutch or Sophie Turner, fans will be watching closely.
Who’s your pick for the next Batgirl?
#Batgirl #DCStudios #BarbaraGordon #FanCasting #ComicMovieDB #DCU #GothamKnights
